Wednesday Season 2: Part 1 Brings Charm, Drama, But Underwhelms in the End

Welcome back to Nevermore Academy. Class is back in session, and the stakes are higher than ever for Wednesday Addams (Jenna Ortega) on Wednesday Season 2: Part 1.

After a busy summer catching serial killers with her psychic abilities and giving the killers a treacherous end, Wednesday returns to the academy expecting her biggest problem to be the fact that her brother, Pugsley (Isaac Ordonez), now attends the same school.

Unfortunately, Wednesday doesn’t have much time to relax or work on her book because, to no one’s surprise, something dark and eerie is headed for these outcasts once again.

With Season 1 being such a hit, it’s exciting to see fan-favorite characters back on screen together, knowing a full season of mystery and horror is coming their way.

But unlike the first season, the show’s release is split into two parts, and right now, the season isn’t looking entirely promising.

Despite having a strong and engaging premise, Wednesday now has a stalker, her psychic abilities are causing her to bleed black from her eyes for an unknown reason, and she’s trying to figure out who controls the killer crows connected to Enid’s (Emma Myers) possible death. There’s a lot to unpack.

On top of Wednesday’s drama, we also get a deeper look into the Addams family and their relationships.

Two standouts of the season so far are Pugsley, trying to figure out who he is away from his family while navigating the tricky world of teenage friendship, and Wednesday’s complicated relationship with Morticia (Catherine Zeta-Jones).

Even as an Addams, finding common ground and forming a close bond with your mother can be a challenge.

Surprisingly, even with its darker tone, the show tackles heartwarming themes like family and friendship struggles. Teenage years are a defining time to discover who you are and what to expect in adulthood, but they can also be some of the most difficult socially.

Enid and Wednesday have always had a golden-retriever-meets-black-cat dynamic. Despite their differences, they’ve learned to support each other through thick and thin.

But this season, Enid develops feelings for the leader of the wolfpack, Bruno (Noah B. Taylor), and makes him, the pack, and her desire to belong her entire personality.

Meanwhile, Wednesday focuses on herself and secretly tries to prevent Enid’s death, with the “help” of her obsessive stalker, Agnes Demille (Evie Templeton). Enid grows jealous and insecure.

Both girls have valid feelings, and it’s touching to see such a realistic portrayal of the highs and lows of high school friendships.

The first two episodes deliver in terms of visual, emotional, and narrative impact. But Wednesday Season 2 Episode 3, “Call of the Woe,” and Wednesday Season 2 Episode 4, “If These Woes Could Talk,” take a downward turn.

The identity of the person controlling the crows is revealed in one of the most anticlimactic scenes possible, just a face reveal and explanation. This “big” character only appeared briefly once before, making it hard to connect with or care about them.

The crow storyline ends abruptly when the character is chased away by inmates at Willow Hill Psychiatric Hospital. Before we can process it, the focus shifts to Tyler (Hunter Doohan) escaping Willow Hill.

The pacing feels rushed, and the payoff doesn’t match the buildup. Adding to the frustration, you’d expect Part 1 to end on a massive cliffhanger to excite fans for Wednesday Season 2: Part 2.

Instead, the season closes with Wednesday being thrown out of a second-floor window by Tyler in Hyde form. She lies unconscious and in a coma on the ground, obviously not dead, since Part 2 is coming and the show is already renewed for Season 3.

It’s a bit of a letdown considering the season’s potential and numerous plotlines.

Still, the performances and visual storytelling are stellar. Jenna Ortega is born to play Wednesday. Even with a rocky start to the second season, the cast throws themselves into their roles, pulling us back into the world of Nevermore and the Addams family.

Only time will tell what Wednesday Season 2: Part 2 holds for Wednesday and her friends, but here’s hoping it’s only up from here, and that the season ends with a bang.

---

What did you think of this episode of Wednesday Season 2: Part 1? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!

Critic Rating:

Audience Rating:

 

Wednesday Season 2: Part 1 is out now with Part 2 releasing on September 3 on Netflix.

Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!

Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!