9-1-1 Season 10 Episode 6 Review: Et Tu?
The most symbolic moment on 9-1-1 Season 10 Episode 6, “Et Tu?” is Eddie pulling a knife out of a man’s back. And that’s saying something since the episode opens with an incident that leads to an exploding pile of crap.
Much like the title suggests, “Et Tu?” focuses on Eddie’s perceived betrayal of Buck and the consequences of that. I say perceived, because in a conversation with Maddie, Eddie explains his reasoning in a way that really does seem like he took in Theo as a way to help Buck — not to hurt him.
This says a lot about their bond, and about the found family aspect of 9-1-1 in general.

The fact that Theo already has such a connection with everyone else at the 118 is just one of the reasons Eddie feels like taking Theo in makes sense. It uproots his life much less since he already has all of those connections.
What’s frustrating is how fast this all moves. Eddie fostering Theo is no small thing, so it’s a shame we don’t see what that looks like in more detail.
There is some relief in the fact that Buck and Eddie make amends by the end of the episode. Buck being on crutches is the catalyst for a whole series of events that leads him to understand Eddie had good intentions.
Oliver Stark was really on crutches, suffering from an injured ankle, at the time of filming, so it’s impressive to see just how much that affected the storytelling. Despite there being no explanation whatsoever for how Buck got injured (which is very frustrating), that injury leads to a deeper exploration of his character by revisiting his issues of addiction.

Chimney is the first to ask Buck about how he’s managing his pain, but then Buck also takes the step of going to a meeting. It’s there that he meets a woman named Nadia who changes everything for him in a short amount of time.
After sleeping with Nadia, he meets her son, who Nadia’s mother currently takes care of because of her addiction.
Not long after that, he visits Nadia and discovers that she has overdosed. For a moment, it seems like he might use his crutches to bust in her window, but his quick call to 9-1-1 is enough to save her in time.
What Buck learns from all of this is that there’s a reason Nadia’s mother should be the one taking care of her son right now. It’s a bit of a complicated connection, because while Buck feels he’s not ready to take care of Theo, it’s not the same situation. Still, it leads him to understand Eddie’s motives just a bit more.

I mentioned that the most symbolic moment of the episode is Eddie pulling a knife out of a man’s back, and the reason for that is because of how the two make amends — and how what looks like a betrayal of Buck at first is something else entirely.
The Julius Caesar performance leading to a 9-1-1 call is so on the nose that I can’t decide if it’s brilliant or cheesy. It certainly does make a statement about the bond between Buck and Eddie, as well as the significance of that perceived betrayal.
This episode also brings up the past a bit for Hen, who is reminded of a woman she accidentally killed several years ago when she and Eddie are transporting one of May’s patients to hospice.
He makes a deathbed confession that he accidentally killed a young girl many years prior. Hen and Eddie set out to help the family get closure.
It turns out, though, that the girl didn’t die. She’s alive and well, and she’s exactly the right person to help Hen get some closure of her own. When she tells Hen she forgives her, there’s a weight that visibly lifts off of Hen. It’s beautiful to watch.
Meanwhile, Athena’s past is haunting her as well, and it leads to a dramatic cliffhanger.

ANGELA BASSETT
The detective who shot her last season has been murdered, and all signs point to Athena having something to do with it. It’s still somehow much less interesting to watch Athena these days, in this new role. At least on this episode, the stakes are high, and there’s a connection to past episodes.
However, it’s more dialogue-heavy than anything as the episode builds up to her being questioned by the FBI. More time spent on all of this would go a long way.
Just before being questioned, though, Athena is suddenly suffering from acid reflux in the bathroom in a way that seems like nerves. Instead, it turns out to be a bit of foreshadowing.
During questioning, Athena is presented with a photo of a man we’ve never seen and asked if he looks familiar. The FBI seems to think he’s an inside man for Athena.
But before Athena can respond, things become blurry from her point of view, and she collapses. It appears she’s having a heart attack — and the episode ends with her lawyer shouting for someone to call 9-1-1.
It’s a heck of a cliffhanger for the Fall Finale, and we’d expect nothing less.
What did you think of this episode of 9-1-1? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!
Critic Rating:
Audience Rating:
9-1-1 airs Thursdays at 8/7c on ABC.
Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!
Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!
