Outlander: Blood of my Blood Season 2 Episode 9 Review: Dead Men Tell No Tales
Outlander: Blood of my Blood Season 2 Episode 9, “Another Man’s Shadow,” splits its time between baby-making activities and setting up storylines for next season.
Babies are the name of the game for this episode, with Colum and Letitia mourning the loss of their son as Dougal and Mara learn they’re going to be parents.
However, in an exciting turn of events, the show teases a larger role to come for one of Outlander’s most beloved characters.

From the moment Jocasta was introduced in Outlander Season 4, it was clear Brian’s sister-in-law was a straight scene stealer with her frank but endearing demeanor.
Sadhbh Mailn has followed in Maria Doyle Kennedy’s footsteps with frightening accuracy, nailing Jocasta’s mannerisms with a captivating performance that begs to be explored further.
So it’s a delight to see Blood of my Blood veer off course from the main MacKenzies to reintroduce us to Ellen’s stern sister.
The season cleverly used Grace and Murtagh to cover up the ploy. But as the plan begins to unravel, it becomes wonderfully clear Jocasta is preparing for a larger role in Season 3 as she navigates the fallout of John’s death.
So much of Jocasta’s battle, like Ellen’s, was only touched on in Outlander. It’s exciting to see the show reward us for sticking with it long-term by expanding the scope beyond its core couples.

While we lose what was essentially a romance red herring in Grace and Murtagh, there’s a rich influx of plot here to devour.
Murtagh and Jocasta were a development that wasn’t possible in the books. So it’s beyond exciting to see context as to why they share the connection that they do in the show.
Jocasta saved Murtagh’s life, and Murtagh saved Jocasta and Grace from John’s abuse. It deepens the connection the two have in Outlander. While Grace’s departure is heartbreaking, the choice to double down on a relationship we know we can invest time in is appreciated.
Jocasta’s take-charge demeanor as she stages her husband’s death is fascinating to watch. She is constantly fighting that cold, selfish inner monologue, and while she claims she is doing it for herself, the beauty of Jocasta is that she’s foolish to her own compassion.
It makes Hugh Cameron’s cruel bid to take everything from her all the more upsetting. We certainly have a new villain to root against.

This episode also rightfully gives Colum and Letitia a powerful episodic struggle as they welcome their newborn baby into the world.
It’s a frustrating storyline that clings to appalling folklore practices, but here’s where having several seasons of Outlander to pull from is a blessing rather than a curse.
It’s heartbreaking to watch Letitia expect her real son to be returned to her. Of course, Claire famously interfered with one of these baby swaps when she came across the abandoned child in the woods. Considering this practice happens decades apart makes the ignorance all the more tragic.
The concept of otherness being considered a death sentence is the perfect conflict for Colum to tackle. He realizes in real time that the child is no changeling and that his condition caused the deformity, yet he goes through with the sacrifice anyway in hopes it’s not true.
It’s great to see Colum explore material beyond his Lairdship title, and it’s even better to see this episode deepen his later interactions with Claire in Outlander’s first season.

This season’s penultimate episode is hard at work setting up new storylines to carry into Season 3.
In some respects, the attention to each and every stone that’s been overturned is appreciated. However, the need to cover this much ground without tying the storylines together leaves characters struggling to hold the scene before it jumps to the next development.
While Colum and Jocasta thrive, Maura’s corruption of Dougal isn’t given the time to simmer that it needs to keep her from coming off like a diabolical Bond villain. Brian and Ellen are worse off, with a farming fantasy that feels incredibly out of place in the aftermath of multiple deaths.
As for Julia, that woman is nowhere to be seen despite her murder being the hot topic at the Grant house.
Hopefully, this episode’s hard work makes for a season finale that’s all play as a masquerade ball turns into a spectacular bloodbath.
What did you think of this episode of Outlander: Blood of my Blood? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!
Critic Rating:
Audience Rating:
Outlander: Blood of my Blood airs Fridays on the Starz app and streaming platforms.
Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!
Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!
