Why Sydney and Carmy from ‘The Bear’ Should Stay Friends

Ever since the very first season of The Bear, there have been avid fans of the show who ship Carmy (Jeremy Allen White) and Sydney (Ayo Edebiri). It’s easy to see why this would be the case, as the chemistry between the two characters is undeniable. Their deep bond is an essential part of what has made the show so successful.

However, the actors have mentioned that in the Season 2 writer’s room, there was never any discussion of making the pairing romantic. Although Carmy wants to open up more to Sydney, it doesn’t necessarily mean he’s inherently harboring romantic feelings for her.

Here are a few major reasons why these characters would be better off as friends, even though many people want to see them get romantically involved.

Sydney and Carmy Should Develop as Individual Characters First

While characters have the ability to develop individually within their relationships, The Bear has done a great job of highlighting characters’ individual character development outside of their relationships.

The show does best when focusing on how characters independently approach conflicts and also stresses how the characters need to grow on their own before they are ready to be in a relationship.

A key example of this is Carmy and Claire’s relationship, which blossoms throughout Season 2. However, at the end of Season 2, when Carmy gets locked in the freezer, he has a breakdown during which he confesses that he believes he should focus on work instead of pursuing a romantic relationship.

This demonstrates that Carmy is emotionally stunted in that he has no idea how to handle his feelings without attempting to punish himself for feeling emotions.

In Season 3, Carmy throws himself into work, and his forced independence tells us so much more about his character than his brief romance with Claire.

His obsession with proving his worth through his work shows how his self-worth depends on others’ perceptions of him. This need to constantly push himself to be better at the expense of those around him demonstrates how his independence comes at the cost of personal relationships.

Sydney also experiences a lot of individual growth on her own, notably in Season 3 as she seeks independence. She gets offered a position as a co-head chef at another restaurant and struggles internally with what it means for her to receive this offer.

Sydney’s journey through this decision alone highlights the burden of balancing opportunity with loyalty and responsibility, contributing to her personal and professional development.

Both Sydney and Carmy’s individual storylines offer deep insights into the characters. They reveal that their current states of development wouldn’t support a successful romantic relationship.

Instead, they need to focus on their personal growth to become more emotionally mature and stable. This individual development is essential for any potential future relationship to work long-term.

A Romantic Relationship Wouldn’t Make Sense Thematically

The Bear has always been about the cycles of trauma. Most shows touch on this topic in terms of personal lives, but this show brings this theme into the workplace. Carmy has internalized abusive treatment from his former employer and unknowingly inflicts it upon those he works with, notably Sydney.

Thus, a romantic relationship between Carmy and Sydney wouldn’t make sense. Carmy needs to realize how he continues the cycle of workplace abuse in his own practices. If he doesn’t realize how he’s hurting Sydney, it would be even worse for them to get romantically involved without resolving this glaring issue.

Furthermore, there’s the question of power imbalance. Although Sydney and Carmy technically run the restaurant together, Carmy still blindsides Sydney and operates as though he’s the sole owner of the restaurant. This would make a potential romantic relationship between the two problematic as their professional lives would be mixed in with their personal lives.

A more meaningful direction would be for Sydney to find a romantic partner who shares her love for food, values her contributions, and doesn’t work directly with her. This would allow her to explore a healthy relationship without the complications of power dynamics.

Male-Female Platonic Relationships Are Important

In the television world, lead female and male characters are more often romantically involved than not. Therefore, it’s so refreshing to see The Bear feature the lead female and male characters as friends rather than give them a forced romantic storyline.

This sends the message that platonic relationships are just as important as romantic relationships, a message that isn’t emphasized enough in shows.

Of course, Sydney and Carmy’s friendship has ups and downs. Moments where they collaborate seamlessly and support each other highlight the value of their partnership. Conversely, their conflicts and disagreements add depth to their dynamic, illustrating the challenges and resilience inherent in true friendships.

These ebbs and flows are important to show because friendships aren’t static. Real friendships survive conflict as long as both parties are willing to work through it.

The Bear has a valuable opportunity to showcase a meaningful male-female friendship in which both characters work on the friendship and focus on how to mend their bond.

This would mirror how other shows have shown that platonic relationships work better for female and male characters, such as Ravi and Liv on iZombie, demonstrating the powerful message of how friendships can be just as fulfilling and impactful as romances.

Even if fans do want these characters to become romantically involved, The Bear would be better off focusing on their current platonic relationship. After the conflict in Season 3, it will be interesting to see how Carmy and Sydney’s friendship progresses, considering the growing distance between them.

Will they find a way to resolve their differences, or will Sydney leave The Bear to pursue other opportunities? We’ll be eagerly awaiting for Season 4 to answer our questions and bring our favorite duo back on screen.

—

The Bear Season 3 is available to stream on Hulu. Read our interview with the cast!

 Follow us on Twitter and on Instagram!

Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!