Reality Review: An Anxiety-Inducing, True-Crime Must-See

Tina Satter’s directorial debut brings real-life whistleblower Reality Winner’s FBI interrogation to the big screen. Based on the former NSA translator’s highly publicized leak of classified information to the press, Reality bestows a thrilling, anxiety-inducing story as the events of the crime are exposed.

It’s impressive how much tension the feature builds, considering that Reality Winner’s story is widely known. In addition, most of the film is confined to one room, which can pose a risk to filmmakers when not done right. Thankfully, with a stellar acting trio and mindful camera work, Reality cleverly delivers the material.

Though only clocking in at 83 minutes, each moment feels like an eternity as viewers wait with bated breath to see if the former United States Airforce member will crack. You can’t help but fixate on the screen as you hang onto Reality’s every word.

Even during moments outside the interrogation room, suspense lingers. Garrick and Taylor’s small talk attempts appear disingenuous and part of the warmup process. However, Josh Hamilton and Marchánt Davis are so convincing in their line delivery and demeanor that you can’t help but wonder if they’re sincere.

Similarly, once the agent duo abandons their nice guy act and the investigation intensifies as they hone in on their suspect, the shift in tone is just as persuasive.

One of the many things Euphoria taught us is how undeniably talented Sydney Sweeney is as an actress, and, in Reality, her range is on full display. In many ways, it feels as though the star is playing two different characters as Winner’s cross-examination escalates.

We are initially presented with a laid-back and confident Reality, but her composure deteriorates throughout the interrogation. Sweeney delivers both sides of the coin magnificently, with a compelling shift in body language as the conversation progresses.

Suspense is heightened as Satter creates an intimate, claustrophobic feel that makes your skin crawl. At the beginning of the interrogation, Winner is standing assuredly, in a full-length body shot, but as the rapid-fire questioning continues, the camera gradually inches closer. 

As Reality crosses her arms, begins stumbling over her words, and intermittently breaks eye contact, viewers see her loss of control in real-time, and Sweeney’s performance is hypnotizing. During one moment, Winner sits on the floor, further signifying angst as her confidence dwindles and she becomes a shell of her former self.

Throughout the film, audio clips from the real-life case are played, adding to the weight of the situation while staying faithful to the source material. Reality uses the official FBI transcript for the entirety of the screenplay, reflecting unhindered rawness.

As the film concludes, we realize that Reality is not intentionally malicious but, more so, naïve. Although she committed a crime, Reality believes her offense was in good faith while also exhibiting remorse.

Reality’s biggest drawback is that some viewers may find the film’s intensity exhausting, with fast-moving dialogue that doesn’t allow much room to breathe.

Despite a grueling, tension-filled feature that can be hard to watch due to the severity of its subject matter, Reality is easily one of the best true-crime portrayals of the last decade and an absolute must-see.

—

What did you think of Reality? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

Critic Rating:

User Rating:

 

Reality is now available to stream on Max.

 Follow us on Twitter and on Instagram!

Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!

Jason Schmidt Talks Buddy’s Journey on ‘Grease: Rise of the Pink Ladies’ [Interview]