The 2023 Tell-Tale TV Awards: Results! ‘Abbott Elementary,’ ‘Station 19,’ and ‘Warrior Nun’ Among Winners

The results are in!

Voting for the 2022 Tell-Tale TV Awards has come to a close, and it’s time to find out your favorite TV shows and performers from the past year. 

After having the chance to submit nominations, our readers have voted enthusiastically in three full rounds for their favorite TV shows and performers in several genres.

The first round presented several choices in each, then the top 12 for every category moved on to Round 2. After another week of voting, the top 6 moved on to the final round.

Categories include favorite new comedy series, favorite network comedy series, favorite cable or streaming comedy series, favorite new drama series, favorite network drama series, favorite cable or streaming drama series, favorite new sci-fi/fantasy/horror series, favorite sci-fi/fantasy/horror series, favorite limited series, favorite TV movie, and favorite performers in each genre.

Now, we’re excited to announce all of the winners of The 2023 Tell-Tale TV Awards below. In one case, there’s a tie, with two nominees receiving the same percentage of votes.

Check out the final results from the last round of voting here.

Here are the winners of the 2023 Tell-Tale TV Awards:

Comedy Categories

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Favorite New Comedy Series:

• A League of Their Own
• Runner up: Wednesday

Favorite Network Comedy Series:

• Abbott Elementary
• Runner up: Young Sheldon

Favorite Performer in a Network Comedy Series:

• Lisa Ann Walter (Abbott Elementary)
• Runner up: Annie Potts (Young Sheldon)

Favorite Cable or Streaming Comedy Series:

• Cobra Kai
• Runner up: Only Murders in the Building

Favorite Performer in a Cable or Streaming Comedy Series:

• Jenna Ortega (Wednesday)
• Runner up: Abbi Jacobson (A League of the Their Own)

 

Drama Categories

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Favorite New Drama Series:

• The Company You Keep
• Runner up: Fire Country

Favorite Network Drama Series:

• Station 19
• Runner up: This Is Us

Favorite Performer in a Network Drama Series:

• Danielle Savre (Station 19) / Stefania Spampinato (Station 19)  — TIED with the same percentage of votes
• Runner up:  Tori Anderson (NCIS: Hawai’i) — updated

Favorite Cable or Streaming Drama Series:

• Gentleman Jack
• Runner up: Yellowjackets

Favorite Performer in a Cable or Streaming Drama Series:

• David Boreanaz (SEAL Team)
• Runner up: Chyler Leigh (The Way Home)

 

Sci-fi / Fantasy / Horror Series Categories

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Favorite New Sci-fi / Fantasy / Horror Series:

• First Kill
• Runner up: The Last of Us

Favorite Sci-fi / Fantasy / Horror Series:

• Warrior Nun
• Runner up: Outlander 

Favorite Performer in a Sci-fi / Fantasy / Horror Series:

• Alba Baptista (Warrior Nun)
• Runner up: Sam Heughan (Outlander)

 

Additional Categories

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

Favorite Limited Series:

• She-Hulk: Attorney at Law
• Runner-up: Under the Banner of Heaven

Favorite Performer in a Limited Series: 

• Andrew Garfield (Under the Banner of Heaven)
• Runner-up: Tatiana Maslany (She-Hulk)

Favorite TV Movie:

• Enola Holmes 2
• Runner-up: Do Revenge

Favorite Performer in a TV Movie:

• Millie Bobby Brown (Enola Holmes 2)
• Runner-up: Jennifer Aniston (Murder Mystery 2)

Favorite Animated Series:

• Star Trek: Prodigy
• Runner-up: Harley Quinn

—

Thank you for voting!

Questions about the Tell-Tale TV Awards? Send an email to webmaster@telltaletv.com.

You can find out more about Tell-Tale TV here.

 Follow us on Twitter and on Instagram!

Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!