Two episodes in one night with a cliffhanger we don’t know for sure we’ll ever see resolved? It’s time for another season finale of Criminal Minds!

Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 19, “All You Can Eat,” is, thankfully, not about what you might think it could be about—and has an emotional kick to boot.

Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 18, “Ex Parte” gives us a very personal hostage situation—and a case that keeps you on the edge of your seat for an hour straight.

Insert the “Bad Romance” of your choice, put on some music, and tune in for Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 18, “The Dance of Love.”

If cannibals haven’t been creepy enough and pirates not random enough, Criminal Minds goes directly for our nightmares with Season 13 Episode 17, “The Capilanos.”

Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 16, “Last Gasp,” seems determined to make me want to tear out my hair — at least until the final minutes.

The BAU rages and rallies against a crisis that may be much bigger than they realize on Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 15, “Annihilator.”

It’s bad news all around as the past comes back to haunt Emily and the team on Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 14, “Miasma”

Don’t be misled by team bonding and geniuses solving puzzles — Criminal Minds Season 13 Episode 13, “Cure,” ends with a jarring revelation and a lot of questions.