The Traitors Season 1 Episodes 11-12 Review: I’m Fighting Till The End/Who Do You Truly Trust?
Does the end salvage a shaky season? That’s what we must ask ourselves after The Traitors: New Blood Season 1 Episode 11, “I’m Fighting Till the End,” and The Traitors: New Blood Season 1 Episode 12, Who Do You Truly Trust?”
The Traitors: New Blood has been an inconsistent, cliffhanger-riddled, weird-editing-choices mess for the majority of it. However, the final two episodes almost make you forget all those glaring issues.
It’s a satisfying end with a deserving winner, exciting moments, and a memorable victory. We even finally see some of the good gameplay that Alan Cumming boasted about at the start.

If more episodes were as complete, entertaining, and true to the show’s spirit, the season as a whole would have been a resounding success.
Unfortunately, that’s not the case.
If The Traitors: New Blood is only graded by “I’m Fighting Till the End” and “Who Do You Truly Trust?,” then it would be a solid B/B- season.
Right now, it’s more of a C-/D grade. Nonetheless, these final two episodes give us a little hope that a compelling reality TV show still exists in the bones of the premise. The producers and editors just need to work some things out.
NBC announced this week that it renewed the series for Season 2. The casting process has already begun.

The next season likely won’t air until fall 2027, so hopefully a year of filming and editing helps the show explore other ways to increase its entertainment factor.
The Traitors has been one of the best reality TV show franchises in the last decade. The criticism is only because we want it to stay or become the best possible version.
Shane Beatty winning the season is one of the most shocking but thrilling outcomes we could have expected. He wasn’t a major focus of the season, but many viewers endeared themselves to him during some critical moments.
He comes off genuine, kind, honest, and clever. This cleverness and warmth ultimately resulted in his win.
Everyone liked and trusted Shane. Therefore, it was ridiculous to even consider him a Traitor. He wasn’t most of the season.

Therefore, he didn’t have the same pressures that Joe, Tomica, and Katie faced all season. Some may think Shane’s lack of having to play as a Traitor all season diminishes his win.
However, we disagree. Whether a Traitor or a Faithful, Shane was likely always a frontrunner to win the season.
His likability as a Faithful got him as far as he did. The Traitors had plenty of chances to kill him but didn’t. He saved Victor, and that built unbreakable trust between them.
This meant Victor wanted to save him with the shield lie. That is ultimately what caused Victor’s final defeat. It also allowed Shane to cast suspicion on him, ensuring he was banished over Shane.
Shane is a worthy winner whether he played all season as a Faithful or a Traitor. He just managed to play both very well.

We still think Cumming exaggerated a bit about Shane being one of the greatest Traitors of all time. He is, in terms of someone you really want to see succeed, but not in Traitor gameplay.
He just didn’t have to do it long enough to compare him to the greats of the game. Nonetheless, Shane definitely ranks high among people’s favorite winners.
His win reminds us that the good guy can still win, even if he has to be the bad guy for a little bit of time.
Well done ending for a very wobbly, disappointing season.

What did you think of these episodes of The Traitors: New Blood? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!
Critic Rating:
Audience Rating:
Stream The Traitors: New Blood on Peacock.
Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!
Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!
