Newlyweds Season 1 Episode 5 Review: The More, The Merrier– Maybe.
On Newlyweds Season 1 Episode 5, “Thanksgiving,” James and Jeanie have largely found their vibe, though he disrupts it slightly by asking about turkey day plans.
Jeanie and her kids haven’t been ready to take on the big holiday they shared with her late husband, George. Since James and Claudia’s meals apparently sent them back to another century, he suggests they compromise with a quiet dinner at home.
That “quiet” quickly wavers. With Jeanie’s tendency to invite anyone in need to dinner, the guest list doubles, then triples even before Claudia invites herself, too. It’s especially awkward because James plans to use the night to give Jeanie a new ring.

The crowd grows (but the food doesn’t) as awkward conversations ensue, Jame’s friend Dan is pursued by a con artist, and the ring is lost in a multitude of pies. In spite of all of it, Jeanie and the kids couldn’t be happier about everything.
Eventually everyone sits down to a dessert-heavy meal. When James finally airs his stress, they even find a way to laugh about it. At the end of the night, the couple and kids manage to have a private moment that’s only briefly interrupted by Claudia.
The holidays have arrived, and with them, a touch more sentiment that we’ve seen to date. Sure, we’ve had plenty of cute romantic moments accompanied by a cloying “aww” track, but I think this is the first time we’ve really mentioned on Jeanie’s loss.

I’d have liked to see the kinds of Thanksgivings that her family shared with George. The very idea they could have been even more chaotic is a bit hard to imagine, but she and her kids are clearly up for the task, turkey pants and all.
James probably isn’t so much—but then, he also hasn’t signed up for this. While the stress of a straight-laced man facing unforeseen circumstances is played for laughs, I appreciate that it’s also treated as legitimate in the climactic scene.
As such, we should probably lean a little more into Jeanie’s tendency to make additional plans without asking. Though it comes together, even ultimately helping James, it’s something that could boil over in another more serious moment.

But for now, everything works out, surrounded by the kind of supporting character chaos that we’re slowly getting used to and that keeps things from getting too maudlin. Is it really Thanksgiving if everyone at the table likes each other?
We never get more than a glimpse of the ring, once its been rescued from both a bed of pumpkin and the clutches of Dan’s date, though I’m still curious. James expresses regret that the kids weren’t part of the wedding. Is a more formal one on the way?
Sure, it would be satisfying to see Claudia’s reaction, but we’ve got the rest of the holidays to get through first. If everyone survives the winter intact, we might be able to think about a big white bash—perhaps as the season finale?
What did you think of this episode of Newlyweds? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!
Critic Rating:
Audience Rating:
Newlyweds airs Fridays at 8:30/7:30C on NBC.
Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!
Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!
