Maigret Season 2 Episode 5 Review: Maigret’s Opponents Keep Closing In
On Maigret Season 2 Episode 5, “The Yellow Dog, Part 1,” yet another investigation is used to create absurd allegations against the effectiveness of Jules and his team.
As we know, he’s already been pushed to consider leaving Paris, especially with Louise wanting to settle down and try for another baby. Then a man is shot by an unknown figure outside the 1852 Club, which celebrates the French revolution.
In the dark, we cannot tell whether the killer is the same as a man we do see, who appears with his friendly animal companion just beforehand, dipping his hands in red paint to put “bloody handprints” all over the walls.

The investigation leads to interviews with a couple bartenders, a past suicide, and a horrific crime involving kidnapped refugees in conditions that eventually left four of them dead. Our mysterious dog owner is also a refugee.
After another member of the 1852 Club is killed, the remaining members (encouraged by the narratives pushed against Maigret) accuse him of not doing enough to protect them. Cavre also gets “special permission” to insert himself in the case.
Jules and the others press on regardless, eventually tracking down their suspect at a hospital. When he insists he only left the handprints, Maigret believes him and lets him go. When we see Cavre watching this, we can only dead what comes next.
At this point, the constant barrage that the squad has to deal with just feels exasperating. They keep effectively tracking down killers and yet the idea they’re making all kinds of mistakes keeps getting passed around as gospel by certain authorities.

Even the accusations of going too far are a massive stretch, especially when those pushing them are almost comically antagonistic (Cavre) or too incompetent to be taken seriously (the forced newcomer to the team.)
It’s disappointing that Jules is taking it all to heart. I can understand him being anxious about the target on his back—or so exasperated that he wants to give up– but between Louise and his team, he must know his enemies have no real grounds.
The case is at least solidly written so far. We’ve only begun to touch on some of the more dramatic elements, but that’s likely intentional, adding still more to the fallout we’re going to see in the last episode of the season.

Then there’s the ending. Choosing to let a suspect flee might be the only truly questionable thing Jules does, at least without being able to immediately explain it. I’m sure he has a plan, but does he know what Cavre might do before can follow through?
At this point, I’m not sure how the season will end. Sure, Maigret is likely to save the day and win back his reputation, but I won’t rule out closing on a rock bottom he needs to climb out of, assuming he’s not finally pushed to quit altogether.
I still don’t think that’s likely, at least not unless the series doesn’t come back for season three, but I have my fingers crossed that Jules and Louise can (voluntarily) take a nice long vacation after all this. They’ve more than earned some peace.
What did you think of this episode of Maigret? Share your thoughts in the comments below, and don’t forget to leave your own rating!
Critic Rating:
Audience Rating:
Maigret airs Sundays at 9/8C on PBS.
Check out our latest TV recommendations, updated weekly!
Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!
