Atlanta Season 4 Episode 8 Review: The Goof Who Sat by the Door

Atlanta Season 4 Episode 8, “The Goof Who Sat by the Door,” is the show’s most audacious outing, brilliantly weaving a fictional behind-the-scenes narrative into the foundation of an established Disney film.

If you’re a Millennial, there’s a good chance you wore out your family’s VHS copy of A Goofy Movie. You’ve jammed to Powerline’s catchy tunes, “Stand Out” and “I2I.” You’ve said “Leaning Tower of Cheesa” to yourself unironically. Now, picture award-winning surrealist comedy Atlanta debuting a fake documentary chronicling the rise and downfall of the fictional Disney CEO behind that movie. 

“The Goof Who Sat by the Door” feels so real that you’d swear you were watching an actual documentary on the making of A Goofy Movie. Unabashedly, I Googled names like “Thomas Washington” to see if they were real people. Of course, the storytelling seamlessly forms the backbone of this episode. You’re not even mad at Atlanta for pulling the wool over your eyes. 

“The Goof Who Sat by the Door” doesn’t mark the first time the show has aired an episode without its four leads. Season 3 took quite a few big storytelling swings in that regard with outings like episode four, which is about reparations owed to the Black community from white people with slave-owning ancestors, and episode nine, which followed a mixed-race high school student proving he’s Black to score a college scholarship. 

While some might bemoan the deviations from the main narrative with these side episodes, they showcase the ingenuity of Donald Glover and his writing team and their desire to take on stories we seldom see on TV with gusto and panache. They help kickstart meaningful conversations regarding race and white supremacy’s venomous, iron-clad grip on the world. 

“The Goof Who Sat by the Door” makes airtight, legitimately sound arguments for why Goofy is a Black character and the messages A Goofy Movie imparts on a subtextual level. The writers for this episode, Francesca Sloane and Karen Joseph Adcock, inject so much nuance and richness into Thomas Washington’s journey, along with the intricacies of his life that influence A Goofy Movie. 

You wouldn’t think a boisterous, heartwarming animated film for kids would hold this much depth, from its exploration of Black Exceptionalism, segregation, and Black fatherhood to, as the documentary puts it, “the amount of cheese in African-American diets.” Thomas even names Goofy’s son Max after his child. It’s all believable, and therein lies its brilliance. 

It will be challenging not to revisit A Goofy Movie without reframing it from this perspective. It just makes sense. Atlanta finds a way to add more layers to a staple in Disney character history, with Glover’s beautiful direction fully immersing us in this story. 

“The Goof Who Sat by the Door” also ostensibly tackles Disney’s racist past and mega-slow crawl toward a diversified future. The company didn’t showcase its first Black princess until 2009 and, in 2022, features its first plus-sized lead character in a short film about body dysmorphia. All the above feels way too late in the grand scheme of things. Shouldn’t the most influential company in the world pave the way for societal progress? 

This episode is hilarious and heartbreaking, deftly telling a captivating story about a man who never existed but plausibly could have. The integration of the 1992 LA Riots with the ascension of Thomas Washington as Disney’s next CEO is a genius move that feels lived-in and believable. 

The found footage is artfully shot, with Thomas Washington’s final video evoking a keen sense of sadness. The discussion about Black mental health comes to the fore, and how there weren’t descriptors like depression and anxiety in the ’90s, especially concerning Black people. 

In addition, the cohesive union between the dialogue and imagery is so tight-knit. The latter tells just as much of the story as the former. That end sequence wherein Max saves Goofy with a fishing rod and the discovery of Thomas Washington’s car in the same lake where he took his son to fish is a powerful blending of scenes. It adds more depth to this tragic fictional character. 

Atlanta puts its trademark spin on a documentary, injecting a new perspective into a cult classic children’s film with the sharp humor, poignancy, depth, and surrealism that only it can provide. You’ll never look at Goofy or A Goofy Movie the same way again, and that’s a good thing. 

Stray Observations: 

• The last time we had a B.A.N.-centric episode was Season 1 Episode 7, “B.A.N.,” wherein Alfred appears as a guest in a “tedious interview.” It won an Emmy for Outstanding Directing for a Comedy Series. Rightfully so — it’s easily one of Atlanta‘s strongest episodes.
• Who else found themselves Googling various names that popped up during “The Goof Who Sat by the Door”? The Powers That Be behind this show do an excellent job of making every aspect of this fake documentary seem authentic. 
• Twenty-seven years later, Powerline’s iconic jams, “I2I” and “Stand Out,” are endlessly listenable. The incorporation of backstory for Tevin Campbell’s involvement in A Goofy Movie is so seamless and realistic. 
• This episode will probably appeal the most to Millennials and maybe some Gen Xers. After all, for many of us, A Goofy Movie was a significant part of our childhoods. 
• Did anyone else laugh at the image of the Goofy shoes and gloves in the water at the end? For me, it was a mixture of humor and sadness — the tragicomedy surrounding the downfall of this fictional, cultural figure. That said, the moment when Thomas Washington lets out a maniacal yet broken “Goofy laugh” is comedy gold. 

What did you think of this episode of Atlanta? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

Critic Rating:

User Rating:

 

Atlanta airs Thursdays at 10/9c on FX, with next-day streaming on Hulu.

 Follow us on Twitter and Instagram!

Want more from Tell-Tale TV? Subscribe to our newsletter here!

15 Most Binge-Worthy TV Shows of 2022 So Far